Top Prize Sparks Huge Debate

Share the Blurb:
pin it button Top Prize Sparks Huge Debate

2nd Platoon Under Fire by Damon Winter Top Prize Sparks Huge Debate

When Damon Winter’s feature picture story “A Grunt’s Life” won third place in 2010’s Pictures of the Year International, it was yet another in a long string of awards for the New York Times photojournalist.

But this time, he used Hipstamatic to alter the iPhone photos he took while embedded with a platoon in Afghanistan. And so his win set off a firestorm among photo critics.

Specialist Jake Fisher by Damon Winter Top Prize Sparks Huge Debate

Did Winter break the rules of the competition? Did he break the rules of photojournalism by filtering gritty reality through an app? Is it about the tools a photographer uses, or the unique eye he or she brings to the moment?

It all makes for a healthy debate about how new technology can push professional standards – and the creative edge – into terra incognita.

Take a look at Winter’s eloquent response to all the brouhaha.

And hey, we can’t all be war correspondents, but if you want to push your own creative edge with an iPhone, check out this 8x telephoto lens, designed to use with the phone and a tiny tripod.

Share the Blurb:
pin it button Top Prize Sparks Huge Debate

One Comment

  1. Perhaps it’s best to assume in this photoshop age that all photographs are fantasy constructs of some sort. I think unadulterated images are very rare indeed. Why do people get stressed when they find out that a photograph has been doctored? Unless work is being promoted as an unmanipulated image then assume it is.

      February 22, 2011 – 10:56 am   Permalink

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *

(required, not published)